Clove (
shenevermisses) wrote2012-11-10 06:01 pm
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
11th Throw - [ written ]
[There are too many nightmares. Too many nights spent thrashing herself awake. Sometimes she fully wakes Cato, sometimes she just has to assure him she's okay before he fall back asleep. She's tried to run, she's tried to just go as far as she can, she's tried to roll over and go back to sleep. She can't ignore it, she can't escape it, she can't get over it.
So, late at night or early in the morning, she opens her journal.
She's tired but wide awake. It's a kind of exhaustion, really. She doesn't know how many people will see this, but she wants to ask.]
The Malnosso are always fighting their war, right? There's always battles and killing.
Is there any way to volunteer? To join them? I want to. There has to be a way, so I want to know.
As long as I'm fighting, I don't have nightmares.
[After about two hours, she'll strike out the entire last sentence. It's too private, too personal. It was stupid to ever write it, but at least it will be gone. Some of them have seen it, but she can deny it later. Sort of.]
So, late at night or early in the morning, she opens her journal.
She's tired but wide awake. It's a kind of exhaustion, really. She doesn't know how many people will see this, but she wants to ask.]
The Malnosso are always fighting their war, right? There's always battles and killing.
Is there any way to volunteer? To join them? I want to. There has to be a way, so I want to know.
As long as I'm fighting, I don't have nightmares.
[After about two hours, she'll strike out the entire last sentence. It's too private, too personal. It was stupid to ever write it, but at least it will be gone. Some of them have seen it, but she can deny it later. Sort of.]
[written]
[It takes her a moment to decide if she actually wants to... But they share something now, the two of them. Good or bad, she's not sure, but it's... something.
So she makes a filter. Only about 50%, but it will do.]
I don't understand people here.
[written / filtered 50%]
But right now, she's recognizing that her thoughts on this matter may have been silly. But this is personal. Something between her and Clove that ought to stay that way. Most conversations she has on here never reach that point.]
Me neither.
[written / filtered 50%]
Pushed every direction but the one she wants to go in.
Like the Academy. Like the Capitol. Like the Games.
Even here, there's a "right" and a "wrong" choice. They don't want individual thought. They want agreement. That's the only kind of correct individual thought. Just like every tribute should be unique in their interviews. Unique by design of their mentor and stylist. It's not the real boy or girl on that stage, not really. Sometimes it shines through, but usually it's just the act. Even the outlying districts do it.
But Katniss.
Katniss has been in the Games. Not just seen them, not just heard about them. The cameras are always watching, but some personas can't always hold up. She might not know everything -- like the trackerjacker mess -- but she saw the end. She saw what a proud career was reduced to. Because she trusted someone who wasn't there. She heard her scream and cry.
And, if she remembers... she saw her when she killed Katniss in the woods. The first stab and then all the ones after. She doesn't even know how long it took for her to die. How many blows in killed her. Maybe just the first. Maybe she doesn't know. Maybe she doesn't remember.
But Clove knows this girl knows her. Knows something more real than she's ever wanted anyone except maybe Cato to see.]
Something happened to people on the draft. They called it a disease. They changed. No reason, no... nothing. Not even animals. Like muttations -- they only wanted to kill. Not just the Third Party. People who were sent on the draft, too.
They didn't care who you were. They just wanted to kill.
And people here? Who weren't sick or affected or whatever happened to them. They told me not to kill. That it wasn't their fault.
[Which it wasn't. But it had been a threat. A very potent threat.
Katniss would understand.]
[written / filtered 50%]
Do not take any unnecessary chances.
Especially with muttations. Muttations that haunt her nightmares every night. Of dogs with the eyes of dead children or of lizard monsters hissing her names. How could she ever forget? How could she ever forget how she killed that woman in the Capitol, guilty of no other crime than inhabiting a home with sewer access? Because better the woman dead than she sound alarm. Better for Katniss. Better for Katniss' allies.
There can be no sympathy shown on the battlefield. On any battlefield, be it arena or real war.
She understands.]
They're stupid.
[written / filtered 50%]
[Leaving them alive to try again.
Clove's world has only one kind of mercy: a quick death. Cutting someone's throat rather than dragging the process out. That's what she and Cato had promised each other in the Arena. If they had to kill each other before the final two, they'd make it quick and painless. Not let the Capitol enjoy their deaths.]
They think we're forced to fight, here.
[Forced to go to the battles, yes. She won't argue with that. But she's seen the non-combatants hang back. She's seen them distribute supplies or tend to the wounded. She's seen that they have a choice.
She can't see that as being forced to fight.]
[written / filtered 50%]
[She remembers what Teddy had told her about them. How so many people had been infected. How they had only come up with a cure towards the end of the draft. She had kept her opinion to herself. That those infected needed to die before they could harm the others. It would be a mercy, a kindness. Especially here in a place where death was not permanent.
Otherwise, they might have to live with the guilt of killing a friend or ally. However accidental that death might be, she knew the guilt haunted you all the same. It never stopped. No, better to be haunted by your own death than the death you inflected on others.
Except, she can't bring herself to agree with Clove on everything. It's that second sentence that brings a frown to her face. Clove had died in the 74th Hunger Games. Clove hadn't been forced back into the arena in the 75th. She never had to fight in an uprising against the Capitol.
They view fighting as something very different.]
I think we are forced to fight. The drafts don't give you an option.
[written / filtered 50%]
[There's no disagreement that far. There is no choice about going with the droids. The metal Peacekeepers. But it's not what Clove sees as fighting. She has only the Games, has never seen war.
And from Katniss? She accepts the opposing opinion. She doesn't agree, but this is a girl who knows what Panem is. And has seen more of it than Clove ever will. This is the girl who told her that there are no more Hunger Games.]
It's not the Games, though. [That tells her how to phrase her feelings better. She's not used to talking about things, or even writing them. To having to try and figure out how she feels about things. She's usually told what to think and what to feel.
Independence is a slow process.] They don't have to kill.
[written / filtered 50%]
[Not entirely, but just enough to count. People fight, people kill, people die. The arena is bigger. The jobs more numerous. The tactics more complex. Not everyone has to fight. Like Clove said, not everyone has to kill.
But when on the battlefield, when faced with defending yourself and your own, killing is the simplest solution. Like in the Hunger Games, it's the only way to ensure that you'll see tomorrow.
And that's only the beginning of the similarities. For her, the list becomes much more personal.]
But we're still just game pieces in the end.
[written / filtered 50%]
There's one simple question.
A question she doesn't know if there even is an answer, much less if there's an answer Katniss will know.]
Are we ever not?
[written / filtered 50%]
But now he's gone. And she's no longer looking at this world with the same optimistic view as before.
They are game pieces here. Every single one of them brought to this town. She's been a game piece her entire life.
Are we ever not?]
They didn't know what to do with me after the uprising was over. So they sent me back to District 12 until they needed me again. I think, maybe if I had stayed, I might've had that chance. At least for a while.
[written / filtered 50%]
Clove doesn't liken it to Luceti sans experiments and sans draft, but that's what it makes her think of. So they're pieces in a game. She was raised and trained to be exactly that. She was taught that there was no higher ambition. When her name was called and no one stepped forward, everyone called it an honor.
The Malnosso? Are no worse than that.]
What do you plan to do when you go back?
[written / filtered 50%]
I don't know. [There's no reason to lie. There hasn't been, not in this entire conversation.] I was still trying to find something that had meaning again.
[written / filtered 50%]
[She won't return to the point they'd discussed in the woods. That Katniss will still have Lover Boy. Different, from all she's said, but it's still him. It's still a life with him. A life with him and no more Games.
That's a little more steady, isn't it, than any sort of patched together life here, where anything could end in a blink and where, apparently, it's a bad idea to have kids.]
[written / filtered 50%]
It's not like the odds had ever fully been in her favor.]
Maybe. If I ever get back.
[written / filtered 50%]
[She wouldn't manage all of this if they were actually speaking. Her admiration is too great, especially in this moment. It can be dampened when written, but it would show plainly if they were face-to-face.
She's supposed to be loyal to the Capitol, to consider the Games an honor. Yet, she is relieved to know there will be no more. That, should her mother get the second daughter she always wanted, the sister she would never know would not have to fear the Arena.]
If anyone who wants to get out of here can, it's you.
[written / filtered 50%]
How people never seemed to see through the disguise, never noticed that she was a selfish, desperate girl determined just to survive, puzzles her. Even Clove, Clove who had tried to kill her in the arena, who had killed her here seemed to believe it. And she had never seen the Mockingjay propos. Not a one.
Maybe it's a good thing that this conversation is written. Katniss can't trust herself to speak aloud right now.]
I didn't do any of that for Panem. I did it for myself. I'm not some hero.
[written / filtered 50%]
It's not for them. It's for you. And for him.
[Clove could see the selfishness, yes. But that. That was what made her so certain that Katniss... could survive almost anything thrown at her.
She toppled the Capitol. She can escape the Malnosso. Since she wants to.]
[written / filtered 50%]
In a way, she had been responsible for Clove's death in the arena. If the other girl hadn't been so intent on killing her, hadn't been so intent on making the kill hurt by bringing up Rue, maybe Thresh wouldn't have gone after Clove right away. Maybe she wouldn't have been distracted. Maybe she would have been able to run.
She won't be responsible for Clove's death again. For any reason.]
Luceti can find a new Mockingjay.
[And with that, she closes the journal before she says anything she might really regret.]